Saturday, October 31, 2009

The German's Silly Sermon

Palm Sunday Palm Sunday by Kurt Vonnegut


My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I love Kurt Vonnegut!!

I got this from the library not realizing that it was non-fiction and a sort of autobiographical collage (kind of like a blog before they existed). So it wasn't a tight, neat, clever story like Cat's Cradle, but I couldn't help totally loving this guy's writing, and much of his perspective on the world.

Some theological highlights:

-"I don't think anybody ever dreaded hell as much as most of us dread the contempt of our fellowmen. Under our new and heartfelt moral code, we might be able to horrify would-be evildoers with just that: the contempt of their fellowmen. For that contempt to be effective, though, we would need cohesive communities, which are about as common as bald eagles these days."

-"The nuclear family doesn't provide nearly enough companionship."

-"Be warned: if you allow yourself to see dignity in someone, you have doomed yourself to wanting to understand and help whoever it is."

-"It seems to me that the most universal revolutionary wish now or ever is a wish for heaven, a wish by a human being to be honored by angels for something other than beauty or usefulness."

For someone who calls himself at various times an atheist, a Unitarian,a skeptical Free Thinker, and a Christ-loving agnostic, Vonnegut is pretty spot-on with much that I love in Christianity. He named his book "Palm Sunday" and finished it with a sermon. He quotes Bertrand Russell and Jesus in the same breath. And it's a really, really refreshing breath that I find myself never able to get enough of.

View all my reviews >>

Sunday, October 11, 2009

Guilty Pleasures

I'm home alone for the weekend, so it's Risky Business time! I haven't hired any prostitutes or danced around in my underwear (I live in a glass house!), but I have indulged myself Devon-style with:

Apple Cider - I'm working on my third gallon in as many weeks. Hot, cold, sometimes with a dash of caramel sauce. Has single-handedly put an end to my coffee addiction.

NPR - It's pledge drive week, and I still listened for like four hours straight.

Dancing in the kitchen, singing in the shower - One of the only drawbacks of living in community is the lack of opportunity to dance in the kitchen and sing in the shower audience-free. When I spot a chance to do either one, I seize it.

Baking - I'm kind of disturbed by my own increasingly-visible domestic streak. This one hasn't manifest itself yet this weekend; I'm biding my time before busting out an apple pie.

Shopping - Despite regularly touting my disgust with consumerism, I think a small part of me still inherited the joy-of-shopping gene. It only works when I buy stuff because I CAN and not because I need to, and when it's really CHEAP. Yesterday I got a bike lock on sale and four articles of clothing for $30. It felt good.

Convenient Store Cappuccino - I don't like it because it's all that good, or remotely resembles coffee, but because it's comfortable. In Camden, we girls used to trudge over to 7-11 whenever we were feeling down and drug up on French Vanilla. Still makes me smile.

Puzzles & Games - I've wasted a lot of my life on Scrabulous, Farkle, Word Twist, Scramble, Sudoku, and crosswords. And I probably won't stop anytime soon.

Chick Flicks - Most of the time I'm not wallowing in loneliness - I just genuinely like them. The vast majority are horribly written and completely unrealistic, but I guess I like the assurance of a happy ending. Usually after a weekend-full, I'm done for a few months, though.

Christmas Music - Perhaps the guiltiest pleasure of all: I busted out the Christmas music today! Granted, it was in the 30's when I woke up, so it definitely feels cold enough. I'll try to take a break for a few weeks, but honestly nothing beats the blues (or just makes me feel at home) like a good dose of "Silent Night" or "O Come all ye Faithful." **sigh**

Wednesday, September 30, 2009

A Generous Orthodoxy

A book "review" pasted from Goodreads...

A Generous Orthodoxy: Why I am a missional, evangelical, post/protestant, liberal/conservative, mystical/poetic, biblical, charismatic/contemplative, fundamentalist/calvinist, ... anabaptist/anglican, metho (Emergentys) A Generous Orthodoxy: Why I am a missional, evangelical, post/protestant, liberal/conservative, mystical/poetic, biblical, charismatic/contemplative, fundamentalist/calvinist, ... anabaptist/anglican, metho by Brian D. McLaren


My rating: 4 of 5 stars
All the concepts are good. I think I'm with him on about 95% of his theology. But sometimes this book was a little tedious to read. The first chapter of disclaimers is annoying - most people know they can put down a book if they don't like it. I forced myself to persevere till the end, though, and I have several really profound points tagged...

-(Quoting a mentor) "In a pluralistic world, a religion is valued on the benefits it brings to its nonadherents." (111)

-"When Scripture talks about itself, it doesn't use the language we often use in our explanations of its value...authority, inerrancy, infallibility, revelation, objective, absolute, literal...hardly anyone notices the irony of resorting to the authority of extrabiblical words and concepts to justify one's belief in the Bible's ultimate authority...I've never heard of a church that asked people to affirm a doctrinal statement like 'The purpose of Scripture is to equip God's people for good works' (from 2 Timothy)." (164)

-"The Bible is a story, and just because it recounts (by standards of accuracy acceptable to its original audience) what happened, that doesn't mean it tells what should always happen or even what should have happened." (167)

-"As so many species slide closer to extinction, the rare species known variously as 'Christianus environmentalis' or 'Disciplos verde' is making a comeback." (233) HA! I heart puns.

-"For pop-Evangelical eschatology to proliferate...prophetic visions of reconciliation and shalom within history...had to be pushed beyond history, either into a spiritualized heaven or a millennial middle ground...they also had to marginalize Jesus with all his talk of the kingdom of God coming on earth, being among us now, and being accessible today." (238)

-(quoting Chesterton) "Any man who preaches real love is bound to beget hate...real love has always ended in bloodshed." (143)

-"So here's the tension (referencing a Chesterton quote): we must always be discontented with our portraits of orthodoxy, but we must never, in frustration, throw the Subject of our portrait out the window." (297) This meets me right where I am...thanks Brian!


View all my reviews >>

Friday, September 11, 2009

Your Love is Like 10,000 Mosquito Bites

**an oldie but a goodie from the Trail**

July 16, 2008
Day 16, Mile 155.2 (2021 to Springer)
Pierce Pond Lean-to

During my sophomore year at Middlebury, one fateful night probably somewhere near 2 AM, my roommate Renee and I decided to spontaneously pray together before bed. At some point I must have dozed off – still speaking – and uttered the senseless praise, “Your love is like 10,000 mosquito bites.” I don’t remember who noticed first, but it was a good indication that our bed time was long overdue, and it has gone down in history as one of the dumbest things I’ve done.

If I may take the liberty, though – I think there may be an ounce or two of truth to be taken from my sleep-deprived babbling. True, perhaps God’s love deserves a better metaphor than mosquito bites, though I’m the first to admit that his is a tough love. But I think the phrase is even better suited to this thing – this idea – known as the Appalachian Trail.

As we were starting out, Default passed on some wisdom she’d heard from her brother Music Man, who hiked SOBO last year: “Hiking the AT is like hitting yourself in the head with a hammer – it feels so good when you stop!” Who knows how we will feel in 500 miles or so, but that has definitely been the case so far. Here are a few of the pains we have endured 150 miles in: sore knees, hips, calves, quads, feet, backs, shoulders and necks, blisters, ingrown toenails, strained achilles and ankles, poison ivy, headaches, period cramps, stomach aches, black fly bites, at least 10,000 mosquito bites, sunburn, broken shoes, lost packs, dirt-caked clothes, sopping clothes and gear, falling in rivers, stepping thigh-high in mud, getting caught on a mountain-top in a thunderstorm, extreme hunger, thirst, water flavored like iodine, bleach, or with floating dirt, sleeping on uneven boards, roots, rocks, or puddles, innumerable cuts, scrapes and bruises, slugs on our packs and in our shoes, missing shelters and hiking 4 miles after 4 mountains to the next one, sharing a shelter in the rain with lots of obnoxious boys, smelling your own B.O. day in and day out, waking up to mice scurrying all around you, having flies attack your bare bum in the privy, and stepping in your own crap.

It’s hard not to get bogged down in the bad stuff and remember why it is that we’re doing this. We’ve been reading a copy of Into the Wild together that we found in one of the shelters. Like the protagonist, Chris McCandless, we must each be endowed with a little bit of masochism to choose to undertake an expedition like this one. But also like Chris, I think we want to be reminded of the things that matter most in this world, and we know that Nature is a good place to go for that reminder. It puts you in a place of forced humility, where you have no choice but to relinquish control and accept that the world is a heck of a lot bigger than you and your needs and desires. I think this hit me first when I found myself praying – after a long, wet, gross night – that it wouldn’t rain again. NO, I realized, no, God isn’t going to stop the rain just because it makes me uncomfortable. It’s not too small a request – it’s just too selfish.

Unlike Chris McCandless in Into the Wild, though, this group of gals is not trying to escape human contact. We are not attempting to live off the land, and we’re not trying to prove something. I am just as convinced 150 miles in as I was 15 miles in that this is where I’m supposed to be and I made the right decision coming out here. We are fostering a love for the AT that only 10,000 mosquito bites can bring – one built on sacrifice – literal blood, sweat and tears. Here are just a few of the ways in which the AT has given back to us so far: summiting mountains, unloading your pack when you finally make it to camp, napping on rocks, swimming in lakes and streams, befriending fellow hikers, arising with the sun, learning to appreciate the finest contours of the ground on which we walk, taking note of animal and plant life, eating 1 lb cheeseburgers, taking a long shower after weeks of grime and having a new appreciation for what it means to be clean, stopping for a snickers, reading out loud together, a cool mountain breeze, a cold, delicious spring, a warm meal after a long day, a brilliant view, a silent ponder of the landscape, a well-timed yard sale, some generous Mainers, Bluegrass at the general store, all-you-can-eat breakfast, a short day of miles, a moment – like this one – looking out on a pond and knowing there’s nowhere else I’d rather be.

So yes, there is a lot to be jealous of, but there’s also a lot that’s not worth your envy. It’s not always fun and games out here, but that’s precisely why we love it. If you don’t keep hitting yourself with that hammer, you’ll never know the true joy of letting up.

Ciao, and love to all,

Flamebo

Friday, February 6, 2009

Saying Goodbye to Granny


This was written for my grandma's memorial service in August of 2007.

Sooo…Granny…where to begin? I think Granny and I were kindred spirits. She just understood me and loved me in a way that was far below the surface. Now this is not to say that we always wanted the same things. I remember once when I talked about going on a mission trip and she exclaimed, “You know what the worst job in the world would be? To be a missionary’s wife!” First of all, I think I can safely say that my career aspirations go beyond being somebody’s wife, and second of all, I’m not sure it would even be all that bad to be a missionary... But that’s beside the point. The point is that Granny would be there for me no matter what I chose. She was an unconditional lover. Sometimes she would give not-so-subtle hints, like a birthday present of a pile of postcards stamped and addressed to her, but she’d forgive me if I forgot to send any of them or just wrote “I love you” on all of them and mailed them a week before I came home. Anytime you’d tell her “I’m sorry, Granny,” you’d hear back, “You’re the sorriest creature I’ve ever met!” It’s basically true.

Now that I think about it, her one gripe with Christianity was always that she didn’t like thinking about herself as a sinner. I don’t think she thought she never did anything wrong – Granny is probably to blame for 95% of my rule-breaking genes – she just didn’t believe in condemning people. In actuality, she was probably more in step with Jesus than most of us on this point. Flaws weren’t important to her; grace was. True, it’s part of a grandmother’s job to tell her granddaughter that she’s beautiful and amazing and the best dancer the world has ever seen…but as far as I can tell, she meant it. She made me feel like a princess all the time. I wear the title GDG – Granny’s Darling Girl – like a crown. I think that’s how Jesus sees me, too, as his darling girl.

Just like Jesus’ crown, sometimes Granny’s crown was hard to wear in public, though. I’ll just name the first embarrassing examples that come to mind, but they’re innumerable…there was the time I walked with her into a very crowded, very tense doctor’s office the day before Christmas Eve, and she broke the silence by picking up a parenting magazine and asking me very loudly and indignantly, “When are YOU going to start having BABIES??!” Another favorite was Christmas Eve (maybe the same year?) when we were visiting a friend’s church, and Granny leaned over to me during the service and said in NOTHING like a whisper, “I’m so glad YOUR DAD still has all his hair,” referencing the poor man sitting in front of us. And you can’t forget the entire weekend of my graduation from Middlebury, where the highlight was perhaps at the Religion Department luncheon. Two of my professors – a nun and a rabbi – almost spit out their food when Granny told the story of how she wished the “Japs had won” because her hangover was so bad after all the V-J day partying. At least the story had a good moral – never, ever, get drunk. Once was enough.

Well, I don’t feel like I’ve touched much on who my Granny was – someone who loved a lot and spread a lot of joy – but she was so much more. One Christmas, I gave each of my family members a “personal Bible verse” that I embroidered haphazardly on little ornaments. Granny’s was Joshua 1:5: “As I was with Moses, so I will be with you; I will never leave you nor forsake you.” I know that God kept his promise for her – especially in the hardest part of her final battle – and now my prayer is that as we fight all our own present battles and those yet to come, Granny will be standing at the side of the Lord, holding our hands, reminding us that we’re loved in spite of being “sorry creatures,” and never, ever leaving or forsaking us.

Thursday, January 22, 2009

Self-motivation

Look what I just found on the RASA website...once upon a time, I was a real dancer!


Some Biblical Economics

An informal essay for my Intro to Microfinance class at Eastern University, composed 6/9/08.
************

What does the Bible have to say about interest rates? Though this specific question is not one I've spent much time pondering, it falls within the broader inquiry, What are biblical economics? The answer – if there is indeed an answer – is fodder for a dissertation and hardly a three-page essay. Nevertheless, I will attempt to quickly sketch my views and wherever possible, apply them to what I know of work in the microfinance industry. My first instinct, as a student of the digital age, was to begin by doing a word search of the Bible for the word “interest”. Though this turned up some intriguing passages, I was also reminded of the dangers of “proof-texting” - using short Bible texts out of context to justify a particular opinion. Instead, I prefer to read the Bible as metanarrative – a unified story that conveys a set of themes that apply to life. Thus, the passages cited represent a semi-random sampling of references to Bible-wide themes like shabat (sabbath) and charis(grace) that in turn have implications for the use of interest rates in microfinance institutions.

Biblical scholar, Ched Myers, asserts that one of the first major economic lessons of the Bible comes when the Israelites, under the leadership of Moses, have escaped the Egyptian empire and are preparing to enter their own promised land. The story of the manna in Exodus 16 contains at least three major injunctions for the new covenental society, frameworks that are later applied throughout the Bible (e.g., by the apostle Paul in 2 Corinthians 8:14-15). The first of these comes in verses 16-18, when the Lord gives Moses the command, “Each one is to gather as much as he needs.” “As much,” or “enough,” is a complicated concept, but there is a clear relativity to it. More surprisingly, the relativity of God's provision is based on need, not achievement, inheritance, or faith. Myers responds to this first injunction with the comment:

  • The Bible recognizes that inequalities will inevitably arise in "fallen" society—a realism it shares with the worldview of modern capitalism. Unlike the social Darwinism of the latter, however, the biblical vision refuses to stipulate that injustice is therefore a permanent condition. Instead, God's people are instructed to dismantle, on a regular basis, the fundamental patterns and structures of stratified wealth and power, so that there is "enough for everyone." (Myers1 24)
The second principle of the manna story comes in verses 19-20, when the Israelites are told not to store up any of God's miracle food for the next day. When compared to the normal practices of today's society, this lesson appears ludicrous. Yet it is repeated throughout scriptural law and parable, for manna – like mammon – is not ours to hoard. If we do, it crawls with maggots and rots! Finally, Exodus 16 addresses a concept begun in Genesis 1 – that of sabbath discipline. In verses 22-30, God instructs the desert-wanderers to take an extra days' shares on the sixth day so that they can rest from the work of gathering on the seventh. Together, these three principles outline what Myers terms “sabbath economics,” and they can be seen applied specifically to the concept of interest as the Hebrew Bible continues.

Passages of Mosaic law referring directly to the charging of interest include Exodus 22:25, Leviticus 25:36-37, and Deuteronomy 23:19-20. In summary, they all say, “charge no interest.” They do qualify this statement by suggesting that it only applies to “countrymen” or fellow Israelites, which makes sense in the Hebrew Bible context of God focusing blessings and rebukes on a chosen group of people. It is notable, however, that none of the passages says “excessive interest” or “usurious interest” - just “interest.” The children of God are induced to differentiate themselves from the moneylenders, who presumably use interest rates to exploit the poor. The instructions to not charge interest come amidst warnings to not mistreat foreigners, not take advantage of widows and orphans (the helpless), and not blaspheme God. The best contextual justification given for this command – aside from its alignment with the sabbath principles stated above – is the statement, “I am the Lord your God, who brought you out of Egypt to give you the land of Canaan and to be your God” (Leviticus 25:38). In other words, charging interest is like selling a birthday present for profit – it's the ultimate insult you can pay to the gift-giver.

References to interest rates also appear in the Hebrew Bible's poetic and prophetic books. Proverbs 28:8 reads, “He who increases his wealth by exorbitant interest amasses it for another, who will be kind to the poor.” Like many of the proverbs, this is a bit of a paradoxical riddle; the essence is that wealth belongs to the righteous, not the hoarder. It is not much different than the manna of Exodus, which gets to be infested with maggots if too much is gathered. In Ezekiel 18 and 22, these concepts are echoed once again. The prophet explains God's picture of a man who is righteous and just, saying:

  • He does not oppress anyone, but returns what he took in pledge for a loan. He does not commit robbery but gives his food to the hungry and provides clothing for the naked. He does not lend at usury or take excessive interest. He withholds his hand from doing wrong and judges fairly between man and man (Ezekiel 18:7-8)

An NIV note remarks that “excessive interest” is an extrapolation; it could also be translated “interest.” The righteous man does not oppress with interest, but simply takes and returns some piece of collateral with a loan. This has deep implications if taken at face value in the microfinance industry.

Jumping ahead to the New Testament, there are a couple of Jesus' parables that are often used to juxtapose the Hebrew laws cited above and legitimate interest and other investments. As a caveat, I acknowledge that my interpretation of these parables is rare, so it may be wrong, but I will present it nonetheless and welcome scrutiny. The first of these parables is that of the master who gives some of his servants each a quantity of money. In Matthew 25, the money is in talents, and in Luke 19, it is in minas; both amount to at least several months worth of wages. Several of the servants “put their money to work” (Matthew 25:17) and double their returns, but the one who doesn't is chastised by the master for being wicked and lazy. Usually, the parable is interpreted allegorically, with the master equaling God, who tells the finance-savvy, “Well done, my good and faithful servant[s]” (Matthew 25:21,23).

Ched Myers suggests, however, that this popular interpretation is backwards. Instead, this parable is about what not to do in the kingdom economy. What is his evidence? Item 1: “'Master,' he said, 'I knew that you are a hard man, harvesting where you have not sown and gathering where you have not scattered seed” (Matthew 25:24). Does this scoundrel sound like God? Item 2: “You should have put my money on deposit with the bankers, so that when I returned I would have received it back with interest” (Matthew 25:27). Does this fit with the Hebrew Bible's injunctions about interest and storing up treasures? Item 3: “Everyone who has will be given more, and he will have an abundance. Whoever does not have, even what he has will be taken from him” (Matthew 25:29). Does this sound like the God we know from Jewish history – a God of the underdog, who loves justice and mercy? Another important clue for interpreting this passage is its context. In Matthew, this story comes amidst the parable of the virgins and the metaphor of the sheep and the goats – stories about being prepared for the kingdom of God by taking care of the least among us. In Luke, the story is sandwiched between the account of Zaccheus, a tax collector who gave half his possessions away to the poor, and Jesus' triumphal entry into Jerusalem, another symbolic reference to the ushering in of God's reign on earth. All in all, Myers' interpretation just makes more sense in the metanarrative. He sums it up, saying, “This reading understands the servant who refused to play the greedy master's money-market games as the hero who pays a high price for speaking truth to power (Matthew 25:24-30)—just as Jesus himself did” (Myers2 38).

Luke 16's parable of the shrewd steward offers a similar dilemma. This story, too, is usually taken as an allegory with the master being God. This time, I suggest turning it inside-out without Myers' help. My evidence? Item 1: “There was a rich man whose manager was accused of wasting his possessions” (16:1). Again, does this manager (the steward) sound like a righteous, godly fellow? Item 2: “The master commended the dishonest manager because he had acted shrewdly” (16:8). Not only is he being commended for acting shrewdly (which might have its place in the kingdom), but the steward is again referred to as dishonest. This is hardly a case of someone redeeming themselves in God's eyes. Item 3 (which is not exactly subtle):

  • "Whoever can be trusted with very little can also be trusted with much, and whoever is dishonest with very little will also be dishonest with much. So if you have not been trustworthy in handling worldly wealth, who will trust you with true riches? And if you have not been trustworthy with someone else's property, who will give you property of your own? No servant can serve two masters. Either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to the one and despise the other. You cannot serve both God and Money.” The Pharisees, who loved money, heard all this and were sneering at Jesus. He said to them, “You are the ones who justify yourselves in the eyes of men, but God knows your hearts. What is highly valued among men is detestable in God's sight." (Luke 16:10-15)

This passage that follows the parable implies with utter clarity that Jesus does not want the disciples to imitate the ways of the world when it comes to financial matters, including interest rates. Luke even offers the commentary that the Pharisees “loved money” so that his readers will be perfectly clear who the parable was meant for. In addition, the context of this story is amidst those of the prodigal son and the rich man and Lazarus, which offer messages about reckless, wasteful love and one's place in heaven being dependent on one's service to the poor. The frequency with which these parables are used to justify the hallmark tenets of our modern capitalist economy is frankly a bit disturbing.

In conclusion, the Bible doesn't spend whole books detailing how interest should be dealt with in microfinance institutions, but it leaves an abundance of clues, both big and small. On the small end, one-line injunctions in Hebrew law, the Proverbs, and the teaching of the prophets all say that interest of any kind is forbidden, at least within the Israelite community. On the big end, principles woven throughout scripture such as sabbath, grace, forgiveness, justice, and faith hint that the needs of the poor should be a priority, earthly treasures stand in the way of heaven, and the best form of stewardship is faithfulness and honesty. What, then, is the bottom line about interest rates? Should microfinance institutions take donor subsidies so that they can charge 15% or less, or should they ask for 30% so that they can survive without outside help? Or should we forget microfinance entirely and just focus on charity, because interest in any form is sinful? From the evidence presented above, it is hard to see anything good about interest at all. It is thanks to an interest-bearing loan, though, that I am even able to attend Eastern University and learn about this important topic! So I want to believe that God speaks in parables for a reason, and that scripture is best applied according to its big-picture themes. Perhaps rather than proposing a development plan and then asking whether the Bible fits into it, we should be starting with biblical concepts like sabbath, grace, forgiveness, justice, and faith and letting the ultimate Sculptor mold us accordingly.



Works Cited


Holy Bible. New International Version. International Bible Society, 1984.

Myers1, Ched. “God Speed the Year of Jubilee!” Sojourners Magazine. Vol. 27, No. 3. May-June 1998, pp. 24-28.

Myers2, Ched. “Jesus' New Economy of Grace.” Sojourners Magazine. Vol. 27, No. 4, July-Aug 1998, pp. 36-39.